Nutrition guide

Should you cook with the lid on or off?

The lid is not a habit but a setting: it goes on or comes off depending on whether you want the water to stay in the pot or to evaporate.

In most kitchens the lid is a habit: food is either always cooked covered or always uncovered. Yet the lid is as much a setting as the heat, and it answers a single question: do you want the water to stay in the pot or to evaporate?

What does the lid do?

A closed lid keeps the steam in the pot. Rising steam hits the lid, condenses and drips back onto the food; the amount of liquid is largely kept.

With the lid off, the steam escapes. The liquid reduces over time, the food thickens and the flavours in it gather in a smaller volume.

The second effect is temperature. A covered pot heats up faster and holds its heat better; on the same heat, a dish cooked covered progresses faster than one cooked uncovered.

When covered?

Everything that cooks for a long time and needs to keep its liquid is cooked covered: dried pulses, tough cuts of meat, pot dishes and most soups.

In steaming, the lid is the method itself. Vegetables cooking without losing their water depends on the steam staying under the lid.

Pilaf is in this group too. A grain that needs to absorb its water both heats evenly and uses the calculated water with the lid on; with the lid off, the water calculation does not hold.

When uncovered?

The lid comes off when you want the liquid to reduce. A dish that has stayed watery, a sauce thickening or tomato paste giving up its water fall into this group.

The second situation is browning. With the lid on, the surface of the food stays moist and does not brown; if browning in the pan is wanted, the lid should be off.

The third is the risk of boiling over. Pasta and starchy things foam as they boil; when the lid is left off, the foam does not spill over the pot.

Is leaving it ajar an option?

Yes, and it is the setting used most. Not closing the lid fully and leaving a gap releases part of the steam and keeps part of it.

This is the right setting for dishes that cook for a long time but should thicken a little: the food does not dry out, but it does not end up watery either.

Where the gap is matters too. The way the steam escapes is adjusted by changing the lid's position on the pot; this is the finest intervention you can make without changing the heat.

Lid and heat work together

The two settings are not considered separately. A closed lid with a low heat gives a speed close to an open lid with a medium heat; changing the lid before changing the heat is often enough.

That is why, if a dish is cooking too fast, the first intervention can be to set the lid ajar. Turning the heat down does not take effect at the same speed on every hob because of the heat stored in the plate.

Conversely, if the dish is not progressing, closing the lid speeds it up without raising the heat and without increasing the risk of it catching on the bottom.

Vented lid or solid lid?

Lids with a steam vent release some of the pressure all the time and reduce boiling over; a solid lid holds the liquid better but increases the risk of boiling over in a pot that is boiling.

A glass lid has a benefit too: being able to look without lifting the lid. Given the heat and steam lost with every lift, being able to see is a saving in itself.

The lid fitting the pot properly is the detail skipped most often. A lid that lets steam escape at the edge does not count as closed, and the water calculation does not hold.

Where does it go wrong?

The first mistake is never changing the lid during cooking. Most dishes start covered and are uncovered in the last stage; few dishes cook from start to finish on a single setting.

The second mistake is lifting the lid too often. Every lift lets the built-up heat and steam escape; a lid lifted to check lengthens the cooking time without anyone noticing.

The third is putting the lid upside down on top of hot food. The condensation collected on the lid runs onto the counter, and this is the cause of the mess most often unnoticed in the kitchen.

Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.

General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.

Find a Dietitian