Do sweeteners take the place of sugar?
The WHO and the national guidelines do not say the same thing on this. What the two sources say, where they diverge and their place in the daily drinks plan.
This question has no single answer, because the two sources do not say the same thing. The World Health Organization has published a guideline recommending that non-sugar sweeteners not be used to control body weight or to reduce the risk of non-communicable diseases. The Türkiye Dietary Guidelines, on the other hand, put these drinks in the "now and then" zone of the daily drinks plan.
Below we look at what the two sources say, where they diverge, the number in the drinks plan and what the divergence means in the kitchen.
What the WHO says
The WHO builds its recommendation on weight and disease risk: sweeteners should not be used for these two purposes. The same announcement also states that the results of the review suggest long-term use may have undesirable effects, such as an increased risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and mortality in adults.
The mood of the sentence matters here too: the source does not say "it does", it says it "suggests it may".
What the national guidelines say
The Guidelines write that a significant part of sugar intake comes from drinks with added sugar, and recommend to those used to them drinks labelled "light", water, flavoured waters, and unsweetened tea and coffee instead of sugary drinks.
But the same page also carries its warning: according to some data, consuming too much of these drinks increases the risk of many diseases. The number given for drinks labelled "light" in the daily drinks plan shows this too — the target is 0, the range 0-480 mL.
Where exactly the divergence lies
The two sources are close to each other on the uncertainty of the risk; where they diverge is on the recommendation side. The WHO does not recommend sweeteners as a tool. The Guidelines, by contrast, count them as a transition item: the target is still water, but for someone coming from sugary drinks they can be used as an intermediate step.
This difference is not averaged out. There is only one thing both sources say the same, and that is the practical one: a sweetened drink is not in the green zone of the daily plan.
What it means in the kitchen
Instead of putting the question as "sweetener or sugar", putting it as "where is this drink in the routine" is more useful: in the Guidelines' plan, the priority for fluid is water, and total daily fluid is given as 2,500 mL for men and 2,000 mL for women.
In short: a sweetener is not a solution put in place of sugar but a step that can be used when coming off sugary drinks; neither source puts it at the centre of daily drinking.
The information on this page is taken from the World Health Organization's guideline announcement on non-sugar sweeteners and the Türkiye Dietary Guidelines (TÜBER 2022, Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Health; PDF pp. 55, 57).
General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.
Find a DietitianYou may also find these useful
Other guide pages close to the same topic.
How do you get B12 on a vegan diet?
B12 is the nutrient in a vegan pattern that needs to be planned separately. Which items carry it, why plant milk does not count, and where is the supplement decision made?
How does difficulty chewing change the plate in older age?
In older age, oral and dental health, dry mouth and loss of taste and smell can narrow the range of foods eaten. We explain the cooking, drinking and chewing advice that protects the plate in the two sources’ own sentences.
Getting enough nutrients from less food in older age
In older age energy needs may fall, but vitamin and mineral needs do not; the absorption of some also declines with age. A framework for getting enough nutrients from a small plate.
Understand the label, shop with confidence
From reading labels to shopping with confidence — a practical guide to walking into the market with a clearer eye.