Nutrition guide

Where do opened mustard, ketchup and soy sauce go?

Unopened, these bottles sit on the shelf; once opened, the label makes the decision. What sets them apart is the salt, sugar and acid inside them.

There are bottles that pile up in the fridge door or on the kitchen shelf: mustard, ketchup, soy sauce, chilli sauce, vinegar. Unopened, they all sit on the shelf; once opened, each behaves differently. What sets them apart is the salt, sugar and acid inside them.

What makes these bottles keep?

What these products have in common is that their make-up protects them. High acid, high salt or high sugar narrows the environment that micro-organisms can use.

Vinegar and mustard are on the acid side. Soy sauce is on the salt side, and ketchup on both the acid and the sugar side; that is why none of the three spoils quickly.

But keeping well does not mean nothing changes after opening. What changes is usually not safety but flavour and colour.

Where does the decision come from after opening?

The binding information is always the label. If it says "refrigerate after opening", the bottle's place is the fridge, and this is not up for debate.

For products without this wording the decision is easier, but not unconditional: you look for a cool, dark place whose temperature does not swing during the day.

Giving an exact number of days would not be right here; the product's make-up, how well the bottle closes and where it stands change the answer. If the manufacturer has "after opening" wording, that wording is the answer to this question too.

Why is the area next to the hob a bad shelf?

The bottles used most in the kitchen stand on the nearest shelf, and that shelf is often next to the hob. There the temperature rises many times during the day.

Heat does not spoil these products straight away, but it darkens their colour and dulls their flavour. A red sauce turning brown over time is often down to this.

Light exposure works in the same direction. Products sold in clear bottles change colour faster on a shelf in direct sunlight; a closed cupboard removes both effects at once.

The neck and cap of the bottle

The most common problem with these products is the part that dries at the neck of the bottle. Dried sauce jams the cap and, at the next opening, carries everything from outside into the bottle.

That is why the neck is wiped after every use. With bottles stored upside down the cap is wiped too; that is the surface where the product builds up.

Pouring straight from the bottle onto the plate is a decision too. A bottle whose neck touches the food or the plate makes the rest of its contents share that contact; pouring is done from a distance.

Which one keeps better in the fridge?

For all of these products, the fridge keeps flavour and colour longer. The cost is texture: a sauce that thickens in the cold is hard to get out of the bottle.

For soy sauce and vinegar this cost hardly exists; both keep their texture in the cold. For ketchup and mustard, use gets a little harder.

The middle way is the same here too: the main bottle stays in the fridge, a small, often-used portion stays on the counter and is finished in a few days.

When is it thrown away?

The decision is made with the senses. When bubbling, a bulging cap, a sour smell or an unexpected change of colour is seen, the bottle is not used.

With a bottle showing mould on the surface, no attempt is made to save the rest either. In a liquid product, the visible part of the mould cannot be told apart from the part reaching into the product. Two bodies reach the same point: the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment asks that mouldy food no longer be eaten and not be left out in the open, and gives the reason — moulds can form toxic substances called mycotoxins, and mould does not stay on the surface but can also spread into the product. The UK Food Standards Agency also says that removing the mouldy part and some of the area around it is no guarantee of removing all the toxins that cannot be seen.

The number of bottles is a decision too. The eight sauces piling up in the fridge door are, in most homes, a collection of which only two are used; an unused bottle takes up space and reminds nobody of its date.

The most practical way to reduce this is to buy small bottles. The large size of a sauce used once a year is not cheap; the longer it stays open, the vaguer the decision becomes.

The ruling on mould on this page is taken from the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment's page on mould in food and the UK Food Standards Agency's page on food control at home; that mustard, ketchup and soy sauce sit on the salt-acid-sugar side and therefore do not spoil quickly has not been measured in the Food Library — it is an assessment drawn from the products' make-up, and a label saying "refrigerate after opening" takes precedence over this assessment.

Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.

General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.

Find a Dietitian