Nutrition guide

What should you wrap food in: paper, foil or cling film?

All three sit side by side in the kitchen, but they do not do the same job. The choice depends on whether the product wants moisture or needs to escape it.

In the kitchen drawer the three sit side by side: baking paper, aluminium foil and cling film. In most homes, whichever is to hand gets used. Yet the three do different things, and the choice depends on a single question: does this product need to keep its moisture or get rid of it?

What do the three do?

Cling film restricts the passage of air and moisture the most. It sticks to the container, keeps the moisture inside in and keeps smells outside out.

Foil keeps light exposure out completely and takes on a shape; it is used to close the mouth of a container and to cover food in the oven. It is less moisture-proof than cling film because it does not seal fully at the edges.

Paper works the other way: it lets some air through and absorbs moisture from the surface. This is not a flaw but exactly the quality wanted for some products.

Those that need to keep moisture

Cut fruit, chopped vegetables and everything that tends to dry out should keep its moisture. In this group a closed container is the first choice; if there is no container, cling film does the job.

Doughs and flour mixtures are in this group too. If the surface of a dough left to rest stays uncovered, it forms a skin, and that skin does not blend back into the mixture.

For leftovers, though, a lidded container is preferred rather than wrapping. A container covered with cling film leaks when carried and cannot be stacked in the fridge.

Those that need to escape moisture

Cheese is the typical example of this group. Wrapped tightly, moisture builds up on its surface; wrapped in paper and put in a closed container, it neither dries out nor stays wet on the surface.

Bread is a product that escapes moisture too. The crust of bread wrapped in cling film goes soft; paper or cloth protects the crust without drying out the inside too much.

Everything fried that should stay crisp is in the same group. A crisp surface wrapped while hot softens in its own steam within a few minutes.

The oven and heat side

Foil is used to cover food in the oven; it stops the surface browning too much and keeps the steam in. Baking paper is laid on the tray and stops sticking.

Cling film does not go into heat. It is not used in the oven or under direct heat; whatever is written about its use is on its packaging, and that limit is not exceeded.

The same rule applies to the microwave: the packaging must state that the container and the cover are suitable for that use.

Acidic and salty products

Foil's limit is acid. Leaving it in direct contact with acidic products such as tomatoes, lemon and vinegar for a long time is not recommended; for these products a closed glass or plastic container is preferred.

Pickles and brined foods are in this group too. Even in jars with a metal lid, the jar is kept upright so that the product does not touch the metal all the time.

This does not mean foil is bad; it only shows that not every wrapping material suits every product.

The best option is not wrapping

The shared drawback of all three is that they are single-use. A lidded container that does the same job both closes better and can be used again.

The places where wrapping is really needed are few: covering something irregularly shaped, packing a product piece by piece and covering food in the oven.

That is why, once closed containers are in place, the three rolls in the drawer are used much less often; they become a back-up to turn to when the containers run out.

Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.

General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.

Find a Dietitian