Nutrition guide

How do you thicken a sauce?

There are several ways to rescue a sauce that is too thin, and each does something different to the pot: one takes water away, another adds something. Which one to choose depends on the recipe.

When the sauce in the pot is thinner than expected, the first thing that comes to mind is a spoonful of flour. Yet there is more than one way to thicken, and each does something different to the sauce: one takes water away, one adds starch, one uses what is already in the pot. Which one is chosen decides both the taste of the sauce and the contents of the pot.

Why is reducing the water the simplest way?

Simmering with the lid off over a low heat adds nothing to the sauce; it only removes part of the water as steam. What remains is the same ingredients, with less water.

The price of this route is time, and also taste: as the water reduces, the salt and spices stay in the pot and their proportion rises. That is why, in a sauce to be reduced, salt is left until the end; a sauce salted at the start becomes noticeably saltier as it reduces.

Reducing goes faster in a wide pan, because the surface the steam leaves from is large. In a narrow, deep pot the same process takes longer.

When and how is flour added?

The traditional way of thickening with flour is a roux: the flour is cooked briefly in fat, then loosened by adding the liquid little by little. Cooking it stops the raw flour taste passing into the sauce.

When flour is sprinkled straight into a hot sauce, it forms lumps. If it is to be added afterwards, it is first mixed smooth with a little cold water, then stirred into the pot.

The effect of flour shows after it has come to the boil; expecting it to thicken as soon as it is added leads to adding more flour than needed. Start with a small amount and check the texture once the sauce has boiled for a while.

What does starch do differently?

Corn or wheat starch is added in the same way, mixed with cold water first. The difference from flour is in the look of the sauce: starch leaves the sauce glossier and clearer, flour more matt.

A sauce thickened with starch gets thicker as it cools. A sauce that looks the right texture while hot can come close to a jelly after sitting in the fridge; that is why adding a little water when reheating it the next day is normal.

How much of which starch to use varies with the recipe; the instructions for use on the pack are the first answer to this question.

Can it be thickened with what is already in the pot?

A sauce can be rescued without adding anything from outside: part of the cooked vegetables or pulses in the pot is taken out, mashed or blended, and stirred back in.

This route brings no new ingredient into the sauce; it changes how what is already in the recipe is distributed. Dishes with potato, lentils or courgette are dishes where this method can be used.

A sauce to be thickened with yoghurt, however, needs a tempering step: the yoghurt is warmed in a separate bowl with liquid taken little by little from the hot sauce, then goes back into the pot. Cold yoghurt going straight into a boiling sauce can curdle.

Does the added ingredient count in the calculation?

It does. Flour, starch, fat or cream — everything that goes into the pot to thicken it becomes part of the recipe. For someone who divides the pot into portions by weighing it, these ingredients are also in the total.

With reducing, it is the other way round: nothing goes into the pot, water comes out. The dish ends up weighing less but its ingredients do not change; someone who weighs and divides the cooked dish does the weighing after reducing.

The fat used for a roux counts in the same calculation too. If the thickening step is written as a line added afterwards to the recipe's list of ingredients, the same result is repeated the next time it is cooked.

When is thickening not needed?

Not every runny dish is lacking something. In stew-like dishes, the liquid is part of the recipe and is left that way to be eaten with bread or pilaf.

With dishes that thicken as they cool, there is no rush either. A dish just taken off the hob can come together by itself after resting; the decision to thicken is made after resting.

A sauce that has become too thick can be brought back: a little hot water or stock is added and stirred in. The other direction — taking back flour that has been added in excess — is not possible; that is why a thickener is added little by little.

Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.

General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.

Find a Dietitian