Are seeds and nuts measured the same way?
They sit side by side in the same table, but one is written by its kernel weight and the other with its shell. Every calculation made without seeing this difference comes out inflated.
On a snack plate, walnuts and sunflower seeds sit side by side and both are taken from the same bowl. In the portion table, too, they are written side by side — but not on the same basis: one as it will be eaten, the other with its shell. Every calculation made without seeing this difference comes out inflated.
How does the table write them?
In the Türkiye Dietary Guidelines' table of oilseeds and hard-shelled nuts, one portion of walnuts, peanuts, almonds, cashews and hazelnuts is 30 grams net weight.
In the fractional portion table (Annex 2.1.12), 56 grams is written for sunflower seeds, 41 grams for pumpkin seeds and 57 grams for pistachios — and these three are weights in the shell. At half a portion the same row comes down to 28, 20 and 28 grams.
The line that makes the difference most visible is the handful equivalent: for the five hard-shelled nuts one portion is 1 handful, while for sunflower seeds it is 5, and for pumpkin seeds and pistachios 2 handfuls. The difference comes not from how dense the food is but from the measure including the shell.
The table's own footnote is read here too: handful measures are approximate values given for convenience and can vary considerably depending on how the hand is filled.
The same three items, two different gram figures
The Guidelines give the portion of these three items in two separate annexes, and the numbers do not match. The meat–dried pulses–oilseeds table (Annex 2.1.3) writes sunflower seeds as 1 cup or 5 handfuls or 60 g, pumpkin seeds as ½ cup or 2.5 handfuls or 40 g, and pistachios as 2 handfuls or 60 g; all three carry the note "(in-shell measure)". The one-portion line of the fractional portion table, meanwhile, gives the same three items as 56, 41 and 57 grams.
Both are the Guidelines' own numbers, and one is not corrected to the other; nor is a ratio derived between them. There is no such divergence for the five hard-shelled nuts — both annexes say 30 grams. The divergence appears only in the three items measured in the shell.
What this means in the kitchen: there is no need to decide whether to put 40 or 41 grams in the bowl, because the difference between the two numbers is below the measure's own uncertainty. The decision that matters lies elsewhere: whether what is being weighed is in the shell or the kernel.
Why is it written in the shell?
At home, these three items are usually sold in the shell and eaten from the shell: the shell is removed at the table. What goes on the scales is the in-shell form too.
That is why an in-shell measure is practical: it is the amount put in the bowl. The shells that pile up on the plate are the part not eaten and are not inside the number.
With walnuts and almonds the situation is different; these items are mostly bought shelled, and what is weighed is already the part to be eaten.
Why can the two numbers not be multiplied?
Food records are given per 100 grams, and those 100 grams are the edible portion. Multiplying an in-shell weight by such a record means counting the shell as eaten too.
In concrete terms: how much of the in-shell 41-gram measure of pumpkin seeds is kernel is not written in the records in the Food Library. Because that proportion is not known, no calorie calculation is made from the 41 grams.
That is why no calorie calculation is given for the seeds on this page. The only thing that can be given is the measure itself; we do not have the second number needed to do the calculation.
If the kernel weight is known
With seeds bought already shelled, the problem disappears: what is weighed is already the kernel and can be multiplied directly by the record.
There are records for the shelled form too. The USDA record for roasted pumpkin seed kernels gives 574 calories and 29.8 grams of protein per 100 grams; TürKomp's pumpkin seed record shows 619 calories and 28.89 grams of protein.
The two records measure different products and are not averaged. Which one is read depends on which product is in the bowl.
How is it measured at home?
For a snack eaten from the shell, the easiest method is two-step weighing: the amount put in the bowl is weighed, the shells are weighed again in the same bowl and the difference is taken.
This measurement is done once. For the same product the share of shell comes out similar on later occasions, and there is no need to weigh again.
Even if no measurement is made, the decision is simple: in-shell and shelled products are not talked about as if they were the same number.
What changes when buying?
With shelled products, the decision on amount rests entirely with the container; when eaten from the packet, no limit is left at all.
In both cases, what holds the measure is the same: eating not from the packet but from a small container weighed once.
The portion measures on this page are taken from the Türkiye Dietary Guidelines' tables of oilseeds and hard-shelled nuts (Annex 2.1.3 and Annex 2.1.12), and the calorie values from the records of the TürKomp National Food Composition Database and USDA FoodData Central. The measure comes from one document, the calories from another database; the calculations here have been made with the records in the Food Library, and the values are representative.
Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.
General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.
Find a DietitianYou may also find these useful
Other guide pages close to the same topic.
Is chocolate measured in pieces or in grams?
A chocolate bar comes divided into squares, but the size of a square varies from product to product. The Türkiye Dietary Guidelines (TÜBER) do not leave the piece on its own; they write the grams next to it.
What do “low salt” and “salt-free” on the label mean?
The salt statements on the front of the pack are not free wording; each has a threshold per 100 grams. The Türkiye Dietary Guidelines set out these thresholds in a single table.
What does “low energy” on the label mean?
“Low calorie”, “calorie-free”, “fewer calories” — the three do not say the same thing. The Türkiye Dietary Guidelines set out the threshold for each separately.
How do you work out the gram equivalent of the containers at home?
A one-off job done in an afternoon removes all the measuring that follows. No number is given here — the number comes from your own container.