How should you store tahini and hazelnut butter?
What sets these jars apart is their fat content: the oil that collects on the surface is not a sign of spoiling but the product's own structure. The storage decision follows from that too.
Once opened, tahini, peanut butter and similar products behave differently from most jars: a layer of oil collects on top. This is not a sign of spoiling but the product's own structure — and every decision about storage follows from it.
What makes these jars different?
What sets them apart is their fat content. In the TürKomp record, tahini carries 62.2 grams of fat and 676 calories per 100 grams; the USDA record for peanut butter gives 51.36 grams of fat and 598 calories.
TürKomp's almond paste record shows 30.49 grams of fat and 498 calories for the same weight. So this is a group that carries roughly between a third and two thirds of its weight as fat.
In products with added sugar, the picture shifts. TürKomp's record for hazelnut spread with added sugar gives 51.56 grams of carbohydrate and 32.48 grams of fat per 100 grams; here sugar sets the storage as much as fat does.
Why does the oil rise to the top?
In a product containing only ground sesame or nuts, the oil stays separate from the solid part and collects at the surface over time. The longer the jar waits, the more marked the separation.
That is why the clear layer on the surface is not thrown away. That oil is the product itself; if it is poured off, the rest of the jar hardens and can no longer be spread.
In products where separation is never seen, the contents are different: added oil or a binder is holding the mixture together. Which product it is can be read from the jar's ingredients list.
Stir or pour off?
The right step is to stir. When the jar is opened, the oil is worked back in with a long-handled spoon, stirring from the bottom up; this is done at the first opening, not at every use.
One detail makes stirring easier: storing the jar upside down. The oil then collects at the bottom, and stirring takes less effort when the product is opened.
If stirring in a stiff jar makes it overflow, another way is to empty the product once into a wide container, stir it and put it back in the jar.
In the fridge or on the shelf?
Once again the decision is made by the label; if the manufacturer says "refrigerate after opening", that wording is binding and not up for debate.
If there is no such wording, both have a cost. In the fridge the product hardens and becomes harder to spread, but separation slows down; at room temperature it stays spreadable, but the oil rises faster.
The way that works in practice is to combine the two: the large jar stays in the fridge, and a small container filled from it stays on the counter and is finished in a few days.
The spoon rule
With these jars too, the biggest risk is the spoon. A spoon spread on bread and dipped back in carries crumbs and moisture into the jar; a dry, clean spoon goes in every time.
The rim of the jar is also wiped after every use. Product that dries on the rim jams the lid and, at the next opening, carries everything from outside into the jar.
A fatty product also picks up smells. A jar whose lid does not close fully takes on the smell of onions or cheese in the fridge, and that smell does not leave the product.
When is it thrown away?
The spoiling to expect in these products is not mould but the fat going rancid. If a sharp, paint-like smell comes out when the jar is opened, the product is not used; there is no need to taste it.
If a coloured spot or a fuzzy layer appears on the surface, the whole jar goes. In a fatty product, scooping off the top with a spoon and using the rest is not a safe method.
Giving an exact number of days would not be right here either; the product, where it is stored and how well the lid closes change the answer. The binding information is the "after opening" wording on the packaging, and the workable framework is buying jars of a size you will finish.
The values on this page are taken from the TürKomp National Food Composition Database and USDA FoodData Central; which number comes from which source is written by name in the text, and the values are representative.
Personal decisions on amounts and restrictions linked to a health condition are discussed with a dietitian and a doctor. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment.
General information notice. This content is prepared to support general nutrition literacy; it does not replace medical diagnosis or treatment and is not personal nutrition advice. A plan tailored to you can only be prepared by a licensed dietitian; if you are pregnant, have a chronic condition, take regular medication, are feeding a child, or have a clinical condition, a physician and dietitian check is required before starting a plan.
Find a DietitianYou may also find these useful
Built on the same idea: more insights that work in the kitchen.
What does the date on the label tell you: use-by or best-before?
The date on a pack is not one thing but one of two separate things. Whichever is written, the decision in the cupboard changes accordingly.
StorageHow do you get the kitchen ready before going on holiday?
An absence of a few days turns everything open in the fridge into a decision. Making that decision before you leave also decides what the fridge will show when you open it on your return.
StorageHow do you store fresh herbs in the fridge?
Parsley, dill and mint are stored like a bunch of flowers; thyme, rosemary and sage want to be kept dry. A bunch bought without knowing which herb belongs to which group turns yellow in its bag.
StorageWhy are cleaning products kept apart from food?
Detergent and food sit in the same kitchen, sometimes in the same cupboard. The Türkiye Dietary Guidelines count cleaning products among the chemical contaminants that undermine food safety.
Storage